They Live (1988)
John Carpenter's They Live (1988) is a cult classic. It fuses science fiction, action, and horror with sharp social and political commentary. The film is remembered for its iconic fight scene and its sunglasses-wearing protagonist, but it is ultimately a biting critique of consumerism, media manipulation, and the hidden forces that control society. They Live uses a dystopian premise to expose the influence of corporate greed and the exploitation of the working class in 1980s America. This theme remains remarkably relevant today. The film was adapted from Ray Nelson's short story Eight O'Clock in the Morning.
In this analysis, we will examine the film's underlying messages, its use of symbolism, its social and political commentary, and its place in John Carpenter's filmography.
The film follows Nada (Roddy Piper), a drifter who arrives in Los Angeles looking for work. While wandering the city, he stumbles upon a pair of sunglasses that reveal a hidden reality: the world is being controlled by a race of aliens who have disguised themselves as humans. These aliens have infiltrated positions of power and are using subliminal messages to manipulate the masses into blind obedience, consumption, and conformity. Billboards, advertisements, and magazines that seem normal to the naked eye are revealed to contain commands like "OBEY," "CONSUME," and "STAY ASLEEP" when seen through the sunglasses.
As Nada learns more about this secret invasion, he joins forces with Frank (Keith David), another blue-collar worker, to expose the truth and fight back against the alien overlords. Together, they embark on a mission to dismantle the alien-controlled media and wake up the human population.
They Live is a scathing critique of consumerism and the way in which media influences societal behavior. The aliens are corporate elites and authority figures. They control human behavior with subliminal messages, reinforcing a culture of mindless consumption and blind obedience. Carpenter uses billboards and advertisements that contain hidden commands like "OBEY" and "CONSUME" to show how capitalist ideology is everywhere.
The sunglasses allow Nada to see the world as it really is, and they symbolize the need for critical thinking and awareness. People are oblivious to the fact that they are being manipulated without the sunglasses. Once Nada can see the truth, he becomes a figure of resistance, no longer willing to accept the societal norms imposed on him. Carpenter's metaphor makes it clear that the public is constantly bombarded with messages that promote complacency. The only way out of this cycle of consumerism is to actively question these messages.
In the 1980s, when They Live was released, the United States was experiencing the peak of Reaganomics. This was marked by deregulation, corporate power, and a growing wealth gap. Carpenter's film taps into this zeitgeist with unflinching precision, portraying a world where the rich and powerful manipulate the masses for their own gain, leaving the working class in a perpetual state of subservience.
They Live unflinchingly explores the theme of class struggle, with the aliens representing the capitalist ruling class that exploits and oppresses the working class. Nada and Frank are everyday blue-collar workers who are struggling to survive in a rigged system. Their fight against the aliens is a clear metaphor for the working class rising up against the corporate elite.
The aliens are indistinguishable from humans—until viewed through the sunglasses. This makes it clear that the true oppressors are not foreign invaders, but the powerful individuals and corporations who control society from within. The aliens offer financial rewards to those who collaborate with them, reinforcing the idea that loyalty to the ruling class is rewarded while the rest of society suffers.
The film's setting, with its depiction of homelessness and urban decay, makes the disparity between the rich and the poor perfectly clear. Los Angeles is a city where the wealthy live comfortably while the working class struggles to make ends meet. This stark contrast makes Carpenter's critique of economic inequality and the alienation felt by the lower class undeniable.
They Live is all about conformity and how society forces its norms on people without their knowledge. The subliminal messages commanding people to "OBEY" and "CONSUME" are clear examples of the subtle ways in which authority figures maintain control over the population. The aliens have infiltrated every aspect of human life, from media to politics. They have created a system in which conformity is enforced and dissent is suppressed.
Nada's journey is one of awakening and resistance. After discovering the truth, he boldly refuses to conform to the alien-controlled system and takes immediate action to fight back. He stands up to the aliens despite the overwhelming odds against him, reflecting Carpenter's belief in the importance of individual resistance against oppressive systems. Nada's defiance, particularly his famous line, "I have come here to chew bubblegum and kick ass… and I'm all out of bubblegum," is a symbol of rebellion and empowerment.
However, the film makes it clear that resistance is not easy. Frank initially refuses to wear the sunglasses and see the truth, representing the difficulty many people face in confronting uncomfortable realities. The extended fight scene between Nada and Frank, in which Nada tries to force Frank to put on the sunglasses, is a clear metaphor for the struggle to wake people up to the injustices around them. This sequence is both absurdly humorous and deeply symbolic, and it makes it clear that there are great costs to be paid for resisting conformity.
The film also addresses themes of surveillance and paranoia, which were becoming increasingly relevant in the late 20th century. The aliens use sophisticated technology to monitor and control human behavior, and they do so successfully. Carpenter's depiction of a world in which every aspect of life is monitored and manipulated reflects a growing fear of surveillance in the digital age. This theme resonates even more strongly in today's society.
The film unflinchingly depicts a dystopian society where nothing is as it seems and those in power are constantly watching, creating a pervasive sense of paranoia. Nada's discovery that the world is controlled by an unseen force reflects the anxieties of the 1980s, when distrust in government and corporate power was at an all-time high. There is no doubt about it. The film makes it clear that the real danger is not the unknown, but the systems of control that are hidden in plain sight.
John Carpenter's direction in They Live is unmistakable: gritty and stylized, it uses a minimalist approach to create an atmosphere of tension and unease. The decision to shoot the film in Los Angeles is an effective choice that adds to the sense of realism. The city's urban decay serves as a powerful backdrop for the film's exploration of class disparity and corporate control.
Carpenter's use of practical effects and makeup to create the grotesque appearance of the aliens is simple yet effective. The aliens' skull-like faces, with their bulging eyes and decaying flesh, unmistakably represent the corruption and rot that lie beneath the surface of society. These unsettling designs, combined with the stark black-and-white imagery seen through the sunglasses, undeniably give the film a surreal, almost nightmarish quality.
The film deliberately slows its pace at the beginning, allowing Carpenter to build suspense as Nada gradually uncovers the truth. Once the sunglasses are introduced, the film takes off. It blends action sequences with moments of dark humor. Carpenter's synthesizer score is unmistakable and adds to the film's ominous tone, reinforcing the sense that the world is under constant control and surveillance.
Roddy Piper, best known for his wrestling career, delivers an excellent performance as Nada, the film's reluctant hero. Piper brings a rugged charm and a sense of authenticity to the role, making Nada a relatable everyman who finds himself caught in an extraordinary situation. His natural charisma and physical presence make him the ideal fit for Carpenter's vision of the blue-collar action hero. Piper's delivery of the film's now-iconic one-liners adds a layer of humor to the otherwise grim narrative.
Keith David is excellent as Frank, Nada's skeptical and pragmatic friend. David's performance provides a crucial depth to the film, as his character represents the resistance many people feel when confronted with uncomfortable truths. His chemistry with Piper is undeniable, particularly during their unforgettable fight scene, which is both brutal and absurdly entertaining.
Meg Foster plays Holly, a television executive who initially helps Nada but later betrays her by joining forces with the aliens. Foster's cold, otherworldly demeanor undeniably contributes to the pervasive unease that saturates the film. Holly is an enigmatic and unpredictable character, made all the more so by her piercing blue eyes and understated performance. These qualities contribute to the film's overall atmosphere of paranoia.
They Live is a cult classic. Its bold social commentary and prescient exploration of consumerism and media manipulation have made it a film that continues to be recognized as a seminal work in cinema. The film's themes are as relevant today as they were then, with issues of corporate control, surveillance, and economic inequality continuing to dominate public discourse. Carpenter's vision of a world controlled by hidden elites has undeniably resonated with audiences across generations, establishing They Live as a touchstone for discussions about power, class, and resistance.
The film's iconic imagery, particularly the sunglasses and the "OBEY" billboards, is a cultural touchstone. It has inspired everything from street art to political movements. The movie has also influenced other works of dystopian fiction, including The Matrix (1999), which explores similar themes of hidden realities and the need to break free from a system of control.
They Live (1988) is the epitome of a masterful blend of science fiction, horror, and social commentary. John Carpenter's critique of consumerism, conformity, and class struggle is as relevant today as it was in the 1980s. They Live is one of Carpenter's most enduring films, with its iconic imagery, unforgettable one-liners, and a compelling performance by Roddy Piper. Its exploration of the hidden forces that shape society is as relevant today as it was when it was first released, making it a powerful and thought-provoking cinematic experience.
Expert
Media Sciences
