For The Man Who Has Everything (1985)

Written By Christian Heinke

In 1985's For The Man Who Has Everything, writer Alan Moore and artist Dave Gibbons crafted what many consider one of the most psychologically nuanced Superman stories ever told. Published as Superman Annual #11, this standalone tale uses the framework of a birthday celebration to explore profound questions about desire, loss, and the price of fantasy—themes that would later feature prominently in the duo's seminal work, Watchmen.

The story's premise is deceptively simple: Batman, Robin, and Wonder Woman arrive at Superman's Fortress of Solitude bearing birthday gifts, only to find the Man of Steel in a catatonic state, attached to a mysterious alien plant called the Black Mercy. This parasitic organism has trapped Superman in a perfect fantasy world—one where Krypton never exploded, where he grew up as Kal-El among his people, and where he lives an ordinary life as a farmer with a family of his own.

What elevates this narrative beyond typical superhero fare is Moore's careful examination of how paradise can become a prison. The fantasy world created by the Black Mercy isn't a simplistic wish-fulfillment scenario but rather a complex psychological landscape that reveals Superman's deepest yearnings and internal conflicts. In Superman's dream-Krypton, we see a society in decline, grappling with political extremism and social unrest. His father, Jor-El, is portrayed not as the infallible scientist of legend but as a discredited figure whose incorrect predictions about Krypton's destruction led to his professional downfall.

This version of events serves as a sophisticated commentary on the nature of wish fulfillment. Superman's fantasy is not one of unlimited power or global adoration—he already possesses those things in his real life. Instead, his deepest desire is for normalcy, connection, and the weight of cultural belonging that was denied to him as the last son of Krypton. Moore presents us with a Superman who, despite his godlike powers, yearns for the mundane complications of family life and cultural identity.

The story's psychological complexity extends beyond Superman himself. When the Black Mercy is forcibly removed from Superman and attaches itself to Batman, we glimpse Bruce Wayne's own perfect world—one where his parents were never murdered. This parallel narrative highlights how both heroes are shaped by loss but process it in radically different ways. Superman's fantasy involves embracing a life he never had, while Batman's centers on preventing the tragedy that defined him.

The villain of the piece, Mongul, functions as more than just an antagonist. His gift of the Black Mercy serves as a cruel subversion of the birthday present tradition, transforming an act of celebration into one of psychological torture. Moore uses this framework to explore how our greatest strengths can also be our greatest vulnerabilities—Superman's capacity for hope and human connection becomes the very weapon used against him.

The story's resolution is particularly noteworthy for its psychological realism. When Superman finally breaks free from the Black Mercy's influence, his reaction isn't one of stoic heroism but of raw fury. The loss of his imagined family and life on Krypton—despite them never being real—affects him deeply. This emotional authenticity grounds the fantastic elements of the story and reminds readers that even the most powerful beings can be wounded by the loss of things they never actually had.

Moore's narrative also serves as a meditation on the nature of reality versus fantasy. The dream world created by the Black Mercy is so convincing precisely because it includes imperfections and complications. This suggests that our deepest desires might not be for perfect happiness but for meaningful challenges and authentic connections. Superman's fantasy life isn't easier than his real one; it's just different, laden with its own unique set of problems and responsibilities.

The story's exploration of time and memory adds another layer of complexity. In what seems to be just a few hours to the outside world, Superman experiences years of life on Krypton. This temporal displacement raises questions about the nature of experience and reality. If memories feel real and the emotions they engender are genuine, does it matter if they're based on actual events? The story suggests that the impact of our experiences, whether "real" or not, shapes who we are.

The artwork by Dave Gibbons deserves special mention for its contribution to the story's psychological depth. The sequences on dream-Krypton are rendered with careful attention to architectural and cultural detail, making this imagined world feel tangibly real. The contrast between these scenes and the stark reality of the Fortress of Solitude emphasizes the allure of the fantasy world and the pain of its loss.

What makes For The Man Who Has Everything particularly relevant to contemporary readers is its exploration of themes that resonate beyond the superhero genre. The story touches on universal human experiences: the allure of "what if" scenarios, the pain of losing things we never really had, and the way our dreams and desires shape our understanding of ourselves.

The story's ending, in which Superman receives his true birthday presents from his friends, serves as a powerful reminder that real relationships, while perhaps less perfect than those in fantasy, hold their own profound value. Wonder Woman's gift of a new flower for Superman's garden takes on special poignancy after his encounter with the Black Mercy—symbolizing how genuine connections can help heal the wounds left by lost dreams.

Moore's narrative ultimately suggests that true heroism lies not in being impervious to loss or desire, but in choosing to engage with the real world despite its flaws. Superman's return to his actual life, with all its complexity and limitations, becomes an act of courage rather than resignation. The story argues that there is nobility in choosing to be present in our real lives instead of retreating into comfortable fantasies.

In the broader context of superhero literature, For The Man Who Has Everything stands as a watershed moment in the maturation of the genre. It demonstrated that superhero stories could serve as vehicles for sophisticated psychological exploration and complex thematic development. The influence of this story can be seen in countless subsequent works that attempt to examine the inner lives of superhuman characters.

As we continue to grapple with questions of reality versus simulation in our increasingly digital world, the themes of this story resonate with renewed relevance. The allure of perfect virtual worlds, the nature of authentic experience, and the value of genuine human connection—despite its messiness—reflect modern concerns that echo Moore's examination of Superman's fantasy life.

The lasting impact of For The Man Who Has Everything lies in its suggestion that our dreams and desires reveal essential truths about who we are. Through the lens of Superman's fantasy life, we are invited to examine our own ideal worlds and what they might reveal about our deepest yearnings. Ultimately, the story reminds us that true strength lies not in never wanting what we cannot have, but in choosing to embrace the reality we do have, imperfections and all.

Christian Heinke

middle aged nerd. writer of thriller & sci-fi novels with short sentences. podcaster. german with california in his heart.

https://heinke.digital
Previous

Deadpool (2016)
Next

Bone (1991)