Dhalinyaro (2018)

There is a distinct significance to a "first film." For a nation, especially one whose identity is often shaped by external forces such as geopolitical strategy, military presence, and headlines of regional instability, projecting its own images onto the screen serves as a powerful declaration of selfhood. Experiencing one's own streets, hearing familiar languages, and witnessing the subtle, everyday dramas of life elevated through cinema represents a form of cultural and political reclamation. Dhalinyaro (2018), meaning "Youth" in Somali, marks a significant milestone for the Republic of Djibouti. It is not only the nation’s first feature - length film but also the debut work of its first female director, Lula Ali Ismaïl, making it a uniquely important contribution. On the surface, the film presents a universal coming - of - age story, following three inseparable high school friends - Deka, Asma, and Hibo - as they navigate their final year before university. Coming from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds, they confront a deeply personal and politically charged choice: should they pursue higher education at home in Djibouti City or abroad in France, the former colonial power whose influence still lingers? This central dilemma drives the lives of thoughtful mediator Deka (Amina Mohamed Ali), brilliant and devout Asma (Tousmo Mouhoumed Mohamed), and wealthy, rebellious Hibo (Bilan Samir Moubus). However, to view Dhalinyaro as merely a charming teen drama is to overlook its subtle radicalism. The film is a masterful piece of post - colonial feminist cinema, with its revolutionary power stemming from its specific focus and rejection of spectacle. By moving away from grand, often violent narratives of war, piracy, or overt patriarchal oppression that Western audiences typically expect from the Horn of Africa, Ismaïl engages in a subversive act. She reclaims Djiboutian identity by highlighting the intimate, complex, and mundane realities of girlhood, friendship, and personal choice. In a region "mired in images of political dysfunction," choosing to tell a story about teenagers concerned with exams, relationships, and their futures makes a profound political statement. It asserts the value of everyday life as the primary site of national identity and struggle.

Dhalinyaro exemplifies what filmmakers and theorists refer to as "Third Cinema" - a cinema of decolonization that primarily addresses its own community. It challenges both the external stereotypes imposed by the West and the internalized neocolonial aspirations that persist within. Lula Ali Ismaïl has stated her intention for Djibouti City to serve as the "fourth character" in her film, transforming the nation's capital from a passive backdrop into an active participant in the narrative. This act of cinematic world - building is essential. For an international audience accustomed to viewing Djibouti merely as a strategic port with foreign military bases, the film creates a vibrant, complex, and lived - in visual identity. Through the lens of cinematographer Jean - Christophe Beauvallet, the city comes alive. We feel its heat, the bustle of its streets, and the sensory details of daily life that ground the girls' experiences in a tangible reality. This project of reclamation is powerfully conveyed through the recurring motif of the ocean. Ismaïl, who has expressed that "the ocean is part of me," incorporates panoramic shots of the sea and the port not just for their beauty, but as a profound symbol of Djibouti's place in the world. These stunning long shots serve as a form of cinematic counter - mapping, reclaiming the landscape from a sterile geopolitical perspective and infusing it with local, personal significance. For the girls, the beach is an equalizer, a space for gossip and flirtation. In the film’s triumphant finale, as they leap into the waves to celebrate their exam results, the water becomes what one critic describes as their "freedom song." It symbolizes a connection to the world on Djibouti's own terms, asserting that possibility does not rely on escape. This aesthetic is not apolitical; it intentionally acts to "decolonize cinema." Historically, the colonial gaze portrayed colonized landscapes and peoples as exotic objects for Western consumption. In contrast, Ismaïl's camera is intimate and subjective. Her "lush, evocative" imagery and "elliptical storytelling" create a new aesthetic vocabulary rooted in Djiboutian experience. This cinema resonates with an audience that recognizes their own streets and lives on screen. Additionally, the film's visual language offers a "searing class critique" without being didactic. For instance, a silent shot contrasting a well - dressed man in a café with a young boy polishing his shoes powerfully illustrates the nation's economic disparities. A city - wide power outage serves as a stark visual metaphor for inequality, highlighting the divide between the "haves," who can afford private generators, and the "have - nots," who rely on lanterns. Through these subtle visual cues, the film uncovers the complex social stratifications lingering in the post - colonial landscape, while also depicting a youth culture that merges global influences - marked by ubiquitous mobile phones and modern aspirations - with deeply rooted local traditions. This challenges the simplistic binary of "traditional" versus "modern," offering instead a nuanced portrait of contemporary African life.

The central conflict of Dhalinyaro - the choice between attending university in Djibouti or in France - serves as the film's primary post - colonial metaphor. This decision transcends mere educational practicality; it represents a profound negotiation of identity, history, and future in the long shadow of the former colonizer. Djibouti's independence in 1977 did not sever its deep ties with France; the two nations maintain close military, economic, and linguistic connections, with French as an official language and France hosting its largest military base in Africa on Djiboutian soil. This enduring neocolonial relationship provides critical context for the girls' dilemma. The film compellingly argues that for most individuals, the choice of destiny is not a choice at all, but rather one dictated by class, highlighting a stark lack of social mobility in the post - colonial state. Hibo, the daughter of the elite, is fated for Paris; her path is an unquestioned continuation of her family's privileged status. The family's exclusive use of French at home, reserving Somali only for communication with their maid, illustrates cultural assimilation and exemplifies what post - colonial theorist Homi K. Bhabha refers to as elite mimicry - an identification with the culture of the former metropole. On the opposite end of the spectrum is Asma. Brilliant and ambitious, her poverty makes France an unattainable dream unless she can secure a rare scholarship. Her future is constrained by the economic structures that are a legacy of colonialism. At the ideological heart of the film is Deka, the middle - class mediator. She possesses the "luxury of choice," and her internal conflict encapsulates the central ambivalence of the post - colonial subject. Her single mother has worked tirelessly to save for Deka’s education in France, reflecting a deeply ingrained belief that true success and validation exist "elsewhere," in the West. Deka's yearning for the "freedom" and anonymity of life abroad - away from being known as "the daughter of so and so" - is palpable. However, her ultimate decision to remain and enroll at the University of Djibouti serves as a quiet yet powerful act of political resistance. This choice aligns with Ismaïl's goal to "show Africans succeeding in Africa," challenging the neocolonial logic of the brain drain. Deka's decision is not a rejection of modernity; rather, it asserts that a modern, fulfilling life can be cultivated at home, consciously de - centering the West as the sole arbiter of success. This is further reflected in the film's bilingual dialogue, where fluid code - switching between French and Somali mirrors the nation's hybrid identity while revealing the subtle hierarchies at play. Dhalinyaro is fundamentally an act of feminist filmmaking. It employs a "female gaze," which must be understood within the specific context of African cinema. This concept goes beyond merely countering the objectifying male gaze identified by Western theorists like Laura Mulvey; it encompasses the crucial task of reclaiming female identity and experience from the dual erasures of local patriarchy and the colonial gaze. The film's most radical gesture is its systematic dismantling of the pervasive Western stereotype of the Somali woman as a passive, silent, and oppressed victim, often reduced to the "iconography of the veil and female circumcision." Ismaïl replaces this reductive image with three - dimensional young women who are ambitious, flawed, sexually curious, and fully capable of agency. This aspirational vision becomes even more powerful when juxtaposed with the stark realities facing many women in Djibouti. With a female illiteracy rate exceeding 60%, a labor force participation rate of only 18.7% (compared to 45.8% for men), and one of the highest rates of female genital mutilation (FGM) in the world, the country faces significant challenges in achieving gender equality. In this context,

Dhalinyaro's portrayal of educated, articulate young women on the brink of university is not a naive oversight but a potent artistic intervention - a vision of what is possible and an implicit critique of the structural barriers that persist. The film's feminism is conveyed not through didactic speeches but through the nuanced portrayal of female solidarity. The narrative consistently prioritizes the girls' relationships with one another over their romantic interests, which are treated as secondary. This is exemplified in a pivotal scene: after Hibo suffers a miscarriage in a school bathroom, the modestly dressed, conservative Asma, without hesitation, removes her own abaya to cover her friend's blood - stained clothing, whispering, "girls look out for each other." This single act serves as a profound statement of solidarity that transcends their significant differences in class, values, and lifestyles. It embodies an indigenous, intersectional feminism that grows organically from lived experience, suggesting that mutual support among women is the essential tool for navigating a patriarchal and post - colonial world. This focus is reinforced by the film's narrative structure, which employs a "decidedly female gaze" by intentionally decentering its male characters. Most of these characters are marginal, often unnamed, and exist solely in relation to the inner worlds of the girls. This approach directly counters the scopophilic tradition of mainstream cinema and aligns with what scholar bell hooks describes as an "oppositional gaze" - one that refuses to align with the patriarchal perspective and instead centers Black female subjectivity. By sensitively exploring topics such as Deka's affair with an older married man and Hibo's miscarriage from the girls' own viewpoints, the film grants them agency and interiority in areas where women are too often silenced or objectified. Dhalinyaro is a seminal film whose significance extends far beyond its groundbreaking status as Djibouti's first feature. It is a confident, sophisticated, and deeply moving work that offers a powerful blueprint for a decolonized, feminist national cinema. Lula Ali Ismaïl's film is a direct and eloquent response to the call for a Third Cinema - a politically conscious and aesthetically innovative medium created primarily for its own community. Her explicit rejection of the "Western gaze" is not merely an artistic choice but the foundational principle of her filmmaking, underscoring her commitment to telling a "Djiboutian story - an African story - with universal appeal."

The film excels in creating a "new aesthetic vocabulary" that is both specific to the textures of life in Djibouti and universally resonant in its exploration of youth, friendship, and the anxieties of transition. Ismaïl demonstrates that a small, personal story - rooted in the everyday choices and relationships of three young women - can effectively articulate grand, complex ideas about nationhood, history, and identity in a post - colonial world. Dhalinyaro transcends being merely a film about youth coming of age; it symbolizes the maturation of a national cinema. It sets an inspiring precedent for a new generation of filmmakers in the Horn of Africa and beyond, proving that their own stories, told in their own voices and framed by their own landscapes, are not only deserving of the screen but are essential to the ongoing project of self - definition.

Sources:

Christian Heinke

middle aged nerd. writer of thriller & sci-fi novels with short sentences. podcaster. german with california in his heart.

https://heinke.digital
Previous
Previous

Lady Bird (2017)

Next
Next

Love Actually (2003)