Superman (2025)

In an era marked by cynicism and superhero fatigue, James Gunn’s film succeeds not by reinventing the Man of Steel but by reminding us of the reasons we believed in him in the first place. The release of Gunn’s Superman came at a time of deep exhaustion. For two decades, the superhero film had been the dominant force in global popular culture, but it was beginning to show its age. A series of high-profile disappointments and box-office flops from both Marvel and DC contributed to a narrative of genre fatigue, suggesting that the well of spandex-clad stories had run dry. The cultural conversation was marked by weary cynicism and a belief that there were no fresh ways to tell these modern myths. Into this landscape entered Gunn’s reboot, a project tasked not only with revitalizing the struggling DC cinematic universe but also with reestablishing the relevance of its flagship character—and perhaps the genre itself.

The film’s impressive success is more than just a commercial achievement; it has become a cultural phenomenon worthy of analysis. With a "Certified Fresh" 86% on Rotten Tomatoes, a remarkable 95-96% audience score, and a blockbuster opening weekend that nearly recouped its $225 million budget in just three days, Superman exceeded all expectations. However, the source of this success lies not in the gritty reinvention or somber deconstruction typical of prestige comic-book adaptations. Instead, its power comes from an act of radical restoration. Gunn’s Superman argues that in our fractured, post-truth cultural landscape, the most revolutionary hero is not the one who mirrors our cynicism but the one who boldly defies it with intelligent sincerity. The film thrives by embracing the fantastic, grounding its spectacle in authentic human emotion, and positioning its hero as a moral anchor in a chaotic world. This analysis will explore how Gunn achieves this revitalization by examining the film’s dialogue with Superman's cinematic history, its thoughtfully developed central characters, its unique aesthetic of "sincerity through absurdity," and its sharp engagement with contemporary anxieties.

To grasp what James Gunn’s Superman is, one must first recognize what it is not. The film serves as a direct response to the previous cinematic era shaped by director Zack Snyder, whose 2013 film Man of Steel cast a long, gray shadow over the DC universe. Snyder’s vision portrayed a somber, grounded realism, offering a thoughtful yet often joyless exploration of how a cynical world might react to a god-like alien. His Superman, brought to life by Henry Cavill with a brooding gravitas, was an outsider burdened by his power, navigating a landscape marked by fear and paranoia. While many praised the Snyderverse for its thematic depth and visual splendor, it was frequently criticized for being "dour," "unpleasant," and lacking the intrinsic hope associated with its hero. It depicted a Superman fitting for an age of anxiety, effectively deconstructing the myth.

Gunn’s film takes a conscious and decisive turn. From its opening frames, Superman bursts with bright, vibrant color, and its tone is consistently described by critics and audiences as hopeful, fun, and heartfelt. This film marks a deliberate return to the earnest spirit of the beloved 1978 Richard Donner film starring Christopher Reeve, a time when the hero exemplified uncomplicated goodness. This reclamation is most clearly indicated by the film’s musical score. Composers John Murphy and David Fleming controversially reintroduce John Williams’s iconic theme, a piece of music so closely associated with classical heroism that its inclusion signals a clear intent. While some critics found the new action cues generic and the use of the classic theme "fragmented," the choice itself is a definite rejection of the percussive, solemn soundscapes of the recent past, favoring instead soaring, nostalgic optimism.

The film's most confident narrative choice is its complete departure from the origin story. Gunn immerses the audience in medias res, three years into Superman’s established career as a global hero. A series of concise intertitles quickly establishes the timeline: metahumans have existed for centuries, Superman arrived 30 years ago, and he revealed himself three years ago. This approach relies on the audience's familiarity with the lore—there's no need to witness Krypton's explosion or the spaceship landing in Kansas once again. Such a decision immediately sets the film apart from the origin-obsessed reboots that have often burdened the genre. By starting with a fully formed hero, the narrative can delve into a more compelling question: not how one becomes Superman, but what it means to be Superman in a world that has become suspicious of his ideals. This confidence enables the film to build its emotional core not through exposition but through a distinct aesthetic that blends the absurd with the authentic. The film is filled with what The Atlantic describes as "whimsical concepts and ridiculous side characters." It presents a "candy-coated chaos" populated by oddballs, where the hero faces a kaiju battle, a comically unruly super-dog named Krypto, and the bureaucratic challenges of the Justice Gang, a nascent super-team that includes a perpetually irritated "glorified space cop" Green Lantern. This embrace of the quirky and unconventional reflects Gunn’s early career at the B-movie studio Troma Entertainment, a sensibility he further developed with Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy.

Conventional wisdom suggests that camp and silliness are opposed to genuine emotion, with gritty realism seen as the route to authenticity. However, Gunn’s film brilliantly overturns this notion. By fully embracing the absurdity of its comic-book universe, the film disarms its audience, lowering the cynical defenses that a more "realistic" approach might provoke. It does not attempt to mirror our world, and this freedom allows for pure, unfiltered emotion to flourish without appearing naive. The sincerity feels earned precisely because it exists within a fantasy world that proudly acknowledges its own nature. A scene in which Superman battles a giant monster while expressing frustration over the collateral damage caused by his super-powered allies exemplifies this approach. The goofy premise provides a backdrop for a moment of profound character insight—his primary concern is always protecting people, not winning the fight. Gunn’s paradox lies in achieving emotional realism not by stripping away the absurd, but by using it as the foundation for his sincere human drama. The result is a film that, despite its chaos, is defined by its "warm human heart" and "deeply emotional core."

The keystone of the film’s success is the star-making performance of David Corenswet. For decades, filmmakers have grappled with the "Clark Kent problem"—how to make an all-powerful, morally perfect being relatable. Corenswet, under Gunn’s guidance, addresses this by treating Clark Kent not as a disguise but as an integral part of the character. His performance is celebrated for its charisma, charm, and a "guilelessness" that feels completely authentic. A key insight from one analysis is that his Superman is not an act; the genuine, good-hearted Kal-El shines through both the bumbling reporter and the caped hero. As one fan succinctly put it, he is "just a good dude whether he's Clark or Superman." The film presents him as vulnerable right from the first scene, where we meet him not in triumph but "bruised and beaten," whistling for his dog. His conflicts are deeply human and relatable. He struggles with an unruly dog, Krypto, who tests his seemingly limitless patience; he attempts to cook a romantic anniversary dinner for Lois but falters in the execution, leading to visible frustration. This grounding in small, everyday fallibility makes his larger philosophy of "quiet power" and "hope over strength" feel earned rather than preachy. Corenswet’s portrayal has been widely acclaimed as the best since Christopher Reeve, capturing the classic hero’s earnestness while presenting a version that is distinctly modern and relatable. He embodies the film’s central thesis: Superman’s desire is not to be a god but to be a human being.

If Corenswet is the film’s heart, Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane serves as its narrative and ethical anchor. In a genre that often relegates love interests to mere damsels in distress, Brosnahan’s Lois is a force of nature. She is a "fully formed, three-dimensional character with her own sense of agency," a "crusading reporter" who never requires rescuing. The film wisely begins with her relationship with Clark already established, allowing their "electric" chemistry to drive the story from the outset. Their dynamic is crystallized in what many viewers consider the film's best scene: an interview in Lois’s apartment, where she, as a journalist, interrogates Superman about the ethics of his unilateral intervention in a foreign war. This exchange is a masterclass in characterization, resembling a screwball comedy while carrying serious stakes. It establishes Lois not as his cheerleader but as his intellectual and moral equal, a woman whose superpower is her relentless pursuit of truth. Her internal conflict—loving Clark deeply while refusing to compromise her journalistic integrity—provides the film’s most "humanizing" moments. She worries that their relationship may not work, not because he’s a god, but because her own headstrong nature will ultimately lead them into an impossible situation. This portrayal is so compelling that it has sparked calls for a spin-off series focused on her journalistic adventures.

A hero is only as good as his villain, and in Nicholas Hoult’s portrayal of Lex Luthor, Superman finds his perfect antithesis. This performance is celebrated as a definitive interpretation of the character, offering a refreshing departure from Gene Hackman's real-estate-obsessed version and Jesse Eisenberg's twitchy eccentricity. Hoult’s Luthor is a "venomous villain" driven not by greed, madness, or philosophical objections to gods, but by pure, uncontainable, and pathetic jealousy. Once the pinnacle of humanity—brilliant, handsome, and self-made—he becomes obsessed with the arrival of an alien who can accomplish feats effortlessly. As Hoult explains, Luthor's fixation is on being replaced. This dynamic makes him the perfect foil for Gunn’s sincere Superman. While Superman is guileless, Luthor wields fake, smarmy charm. His malevolence feels chillingly contemporary, reimagined as a tech-bro oligarch—a billionaire akin to Elon Musk—who weaponizes propaganda, social media bots, and societal fears of the "alien immigrant" to turn public opinion against his rival. He embodies the film's true antagonist: weaponized cynicism. Luthor's goal extends beyond simply wanting to kill Superman; he aims to expose him as a hypocrite. If the icon of goodness is a fraud, then Luthor’s own malevolence becomes justified. The film's commitment to its characters shines through not just in the script but also in its production strategy. Unusually for a blockbuster, the highest-paid actor in the cast is not the hero but the villain. Nicholas Hoult, an established star, earned a $2 million salary, while leads Corenswet and Brosnahan, both rising talents, received a more modest but equal pay of $750,000 each. This cost-effective strategy reveals a core philosophy: the studio and director recognized that the narrative engine of this story was its antagonist. By heavily investing in a powerful, nuanced portrayal of Luthor, they ensured the central conflict remained compelling and ideologically rich. Meanwhile, casting less-established actors as Superman and Lois allowed them to be defined by their roles, fostering the authentic chemistry that critics praised. The film's massive box office success, recouping its production budget on opening weekend alone, validates this character-first approach, demonstrating that a well-cast ensemble and a strong story can outweigh the allure of a single A-list name.

The film’s optimistic tone is enhanced by its vibrant visual language. Collaborating with cinematographer Henry Braham, Gunn creates a "bright and inviting" world, characterized by a palette of rich, primary colors reminiscent of a comic book. This aesthetic marks a deliberate departure from the desaturated, "dour" look of the Snyderverse, where darkness often symbolized seriousness. Gunn’s film asserts that visual joy and thematic depth can coexist, presenting a world that feels electric and alive—one where wonder is possible. Gunn’s approach to universe-building further amplifies this sense of a broader world. Instead of a gradual introduction of characters, the film immerses the audience in a DCU that is already populated with wonderfully strange elements. We encounter a cast of established heroes who don’t require their own origin stories in this film. Nathan Fillion’s Guy Gardner is a hilariously overconfident Green Lantern, Isabela Merced’s Hawkgirl is a seasoned warrior, and Edi Gathegi’s Mister Terrific is a brilliant strategist. This approach eliminates tedious exposition and fosters a tantalizing sense of a rich history just off-screen, igniting curiosity about the franchise's future. A mural in the Hall of Justice even alludes to a past generation of heroes, including the Jay Garrick version of The Flash and Doctor Fate, thereby deepening the lore of this new reality. The film’s soundtrack is another essential aspect of the Gunn aesthetic. The score, composed by John Murphy and David Fleming, is anchored by Williams’s classic theme, aiming to evoke a sense of timeless heroism. However, it is the film’s carefully chosen needle drops that resonate most with Gunn’s style. In a high-stakes action sequence, he incorporates the upbeat indie-pop song "5 Years Time" by Noah and the Whale, infusing playful energy into the chaos and reinforcing the film’s commitment to being, above all, fun.

The use of punk rock resonates thematically throughout the film. Teddybears' song "Punkrocker," featuring Iggy Pop, underscores a sentimental montage of Clark with his adoptive parents, linking the genre's outsider spirit to Clark's own identity. This connection culminates in a witty, heartfelt exchange between Clark and Lois, during which Clark suggests that in a world as cynical as theirs, "kindness is punk rock." This single line encapsulates the film's overarching thesis. To further develop these characters, Gunn curated official Spotify playlists for them, giving each a unique musical taste—ranging from Clark's uplifting anthems to Lex's eclectic mix that fuels his ego. This detail enhances the sense that they are not just icons but real people. The film’s most significant innovation lies in how it recontextualizes its hero to address the anxieties of the 21st century. Previous Superman films showcased his physical power against tangible threats. In contrast, Gunn’s Superman pits his moral clarity against a world inundated with disinformation. Lex Luthor's primary weapons are not Kryptonite or a death ray; instead, he wields a sophisticated propaganda campaign and an army of internet bots designed to reframe Superman in the public eye as a dangerous "alien immigrant corrupting the American way of life." The central plot twist reveals Luthor manipulating a holographic message from Jor-El to suggest that Superman was sent not to inspire but to conquer Earth. Luthor aims not to overpower Superman but to undermine his significance. He attacks the hero's identity and symbolic power, making Superman's unwavering commitment to simple, objective truths—embodied in his desperate plea, "People were going to die!"—a profoundly radical act. In a "post-truth" environment, Superman's greatest strength is not his invulnerability but his moral incorruptibility. The conflict thus becomes not merely good versus evil but truth versus narrative. Superman must fight not only for people's lives but for the very concept of objective goodness in a world that increasingly views such values as "old-fashioned." This is the post-truth Superman: a hero whose ultimate battle is against weaponized cynicism and the erosion of shared reality, rendering his straightforward "boy scout" morality more relevant and heroic than ever.

The film powerfully reclaims the immigrant experience as a core aspect of the character, a theme present since Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster created him, yet often downplayed in modern adaptations. Lex Luthor’s xenophobic rhetoric and the government’s alarming readiness to strip an "extraterrestrial immigrant" of his Constitutional rights and detain him in a harsh, privatized prison draw sharp and uncomfortable parallels to current political debates. A key monologue in which Superman confronts Luthor about being labeled an "alien" is highlighted by critics as a moment of rare and moving nuance for the genre, addressing the hero's struggle with otherness. This political dimension extends to the film’s central geopolitical conflict. Superman’s unilateral intervention to stop the invasion of Jarhanpur by the aggressive, Luthor-backed state of Boravia serves as a thinly veiled commentary on real-world conflicts. This act raises complex questions about unchecked power and national sovereignty, explored through tense, dialogue-driven scenes with Lois. While some critics deem these stakes "manufactured" and the analogy "on the nose," they compel the film and its hero to confront the messy implications of a being operating above the laws of nations.

James Gunn’s Superman is a triumph not because it is flawless, but because it is profoundly necessary. Critics acknowledge its flaws: the plot is overstuffed with multiple heroes and villains; the tone occasionally oscillates between sincere drama and silly humor, undermining its emotional moments; and the final act descends into familiar CGI chaos. Yet these are forgivable byproducts of the film’s immense ambition—its desire to be both joyfully absurd and deeply heartfelt, a rollicking comic-book adventure and a poignant commentary on the modern soul. The film's staggering critical and commercial success sends a clear message to a weary Hollywood: the antidote to superhero fatigue is not more cynicism, deconstruction, or gritty realism, but a bold return to the genre’s mythic heart. Gunn’s greatest achievement lies not just in creating a great Superman movie, but in demonstrating that a character's inherent goodness is not a narrative limitation to overcome, but the very source of the most compelling and relevant drama. In a world filled with antiheroes and bleak news, Superman presents a compelling and optimistic argument for decency as a form of rebellion. It reminds us that the essence of a man who can fly goes beyond the ability to soar; it's rooted in an unwavering belief in the man himself—a belief in kindness, truth, and hope. The film beautifully and intelligently illustrates that this belief is still worth cherishing.

Sources:

Christian Heinke

middle aged nerd. writer of thriller & sci-fi novels with short sentences. podcaster. german with california in his heart.

https://heinke.digital
Previous
Previous

Superman, Politics, and America

Next
Next

Man of Steel (2013)